Out Of Context Ben and Jerry’s

I started dating a girl a few years ago, and one night we wandered around Broadway Ave looking for a place to get ice cream. We ended up getting a Ben & Jerry’s pint of Wake & No Bake, and thought it’d be cute if we made it a tradition to share pints and rank them, 1-10, based on cream, topping, and overall feeling. I started a note on my phone and typed in the first entry (4.5, 7.5, 7, respectively), which also ended up being the last, as we ended things soon thereafter.

She’s still one of my closest friends, though, so that’s kinda neat. Don’t let folk tell you you can’t stay friends with people whose tongue was in your mouth. No tongue tastes better in your mouth, though, than Ben and Jerry’s. The ice cream, that is.

Anyway, here are some of my alternate descriptions for Ben & Jerry’s flavor names. All the images are taken from B&J’s website: https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/ice-cream-pints

How I refer to myself after doing leg day at the gym
One day I’ll write a movie where I star as a hunky, young dude who works as a server at a wedding venue, where he convinces married middle aged women to sleep with him. Post-coitus, he asks how that made them feel, and they break down in tears from the realization that the emotional affirmation they get from their marriage is all they truly want. This will be the title.
(If you think I’m crazy writing this role for myself, Joseph Gordon Levitt once wrote a movie where he starred as a sex addict dating Scarlett Johansson. I’m not asking for a lot here.)
I don’t really have a joke for this name, but it does remind me of taking that one extra shot of tequila on a night out, since there’s just one extra, unnecessary “L”
Euphemism for anal sex with an Irish person
What healthcare options the US government provides its citizens. As in, “everything but the healthcare”
I feel like this one is predicated on pronouncing ‘caramel’ as ‘car-mel,’ not ‘cara-mel,’ because the two syllables match the word the original phrase is based on, ‘camera.’ Apparently, this pronunciation difference is a bit of an east coast vs. west coast debate, so I’ll add this as a chapter in my “America Is Way Too Fucking Big To Be One Country” book, right between the chapters “Too Many People For One Person To Be In Charge Of, Even If It’s An Old White Man,” and “Any Country That Has More Than 20,000 Subways Needs To Take a Long, Hard Look In The Mirror”

(unrelated pun: when a narcissistic man stands in front of a mirror he takes a long, hard look at himself)
When your tan friend compliments you but deep down you know they’re jealous
When your jar of Jif is being dramatic
The day they make a nut-themed Mamma Mia, this will replace Andante, Andante.

The movie’s title will be “Macada Mia!” and the R-rated version will include: “Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! (A Nut After Midnight)”
This is such a solid pun from B&J. They use “A” as the prefix meaning “not” (like atheistic or asexual), because, girl, same. I love chocolate so much, it’s not fair. I have no suggestions for alternatives, I’m just never really sure how I feel about puns that need hyphens in order to work. Then again, I’m never really sure how I feel about anything. I’ve used hyphens for puns before, sure, but I feel like for a pun to be truly worthy it has to work without punctuational assistance. As you know, I find all puns lovely and worthy, though I know many of you find them a-cool. Idk. I’ll think about this further and get back to you.
Comedians who can do accents always say that they tend to use a specific sentence to get them going in a particular dialect. This pint’s name is how you kickstart a Scottish one. You’re welcome. Feel free to read the rest of this thing in that voice.
My ex’s and mine breakup, because she’s really sweet and I’m still salty
The carbs I unnecessarily munch on late at night
When you have a typo 50% into a sexting session
How I’d describe my sex life. As in, it’s sweet. As in, it’s hard at first but leave it out too long and it goes soft. As in, enjoy it too quickly and your brain will freeze. As in, have a towel ready cause you’re likely to end up white and sticky
The adult sequel for Bananas in Pyjamas, where B1 and B2 discover what they’re truly made of as they go through the trials and tribulations of adopting a child together.
These jokes.
Between this one and “Chunky Monkey,” B&J almost completed the set of ‘nicknames for your overweight partner.’ Only missing: “Blubbered Lover,” “Plump Chump,” “Obese Silly Geese,” “Wedding Vowed & Cowed,” and “Spouse The Size Of a House
What Mike Tyson says when his mint plant catches the flu
I’m all for shouting out the local Vermont band, Phish, but I feel like you may as well go all out and call it Phish Phood. Keeping the second word with an F pheels phoolish

Four hours into an open bar at a wedding, this is what I ask for from the bartender.
 
It’s a joke about me slurring the word “please.” I’m not sure if it works, really, particularly as I feel the need to explain it here (at least I didn’t use a hyphen!), but I mostly wanted to say something about this pint’s name because I wanted to share the following anecdote:

At a friend’s wedding, a couple of years ago, during the cocktail hour reception thingy, I went to the bar and ordered a whiskey. I’m a beer guy by trade. Not as in, I can talk about pretentious IPAs or how to stir malted barley or something like that, it’s just my preferred alcohol medium, primarily because it’s the largest quantity of liquid out of all the alcohols. While alcohol serves all kinds of purposes (read literally any other essay on this website for my takes about these purposes), my favorite thing a drink does is that it gives you time. In these social settings when you have to mingle, or perhaps when you’re on a date, there’s tremendous value in the act of drawing the glass towards your lips, holding it there, swirling the liquid in your mouth, then gulping it down. The act gives you a couple of seconds that justify a silence; gives you time to think of a response or a question or a new conversation topic or an escape route. Because beer is always the most liquid, it provides the biggest number of these movements, and the most time to think. I fucking hate making small talk or catching up with people who used to be proximate in my life yet no longer are. There’s a reason why, bucko. So, a beer in hand always helps.
Alas, at this wedding, I opted for whiskey. I’ve never bought the whole beer before liquor you’re gonna be sicker thing or anything like that, that wasn’t the reasoning behind this decision. I just thought it’d be cool to sip whiskey.  Don’t ask me why. You know I’m a whore for acting out male cliché performances (read literally any other essay on this website for my takes about these purposes). Also, it was going to be a lot of drink and food for the next few hours, so I didn’t want to bloat up early on, risk being too full or throwing up or what not.
Anyway, after I asked for my whiskey, the bartender asked me what kind I wanted, and, honestly, he may as well have asked me to recite The Iliad. I don’t know what’s whiskey and what’s bourbon and what’s scotch and what’s brandy and what’s cognac. The only thing I know for certain is that dry whiskey is wry. (That’s a rye/wry pun, in case you didn’t get it. It’s a perfect pun, really, because puns are *dry humor* which is exactly what the word *wry* means, and, in case you haven’t noticed, *wry* and *rye* are homophones, and rye is a kind whiskey. See, like I said earlier about the Chocolatey Love A-fair, puns don’t require hyphens to be easily understandable.)
Anyway, the bartender asked, and I remained as silent as the G in cognac or the spot in a woman’s body during intercourse with a straight man. I eventually blurted out something along the lines of Honestly whatever dude I just want to walk away and forget this ever happened. He asked if Maker’s is okay, except because this wedding was in Israel he pronounced Maker’s with a Hebrew accent, which sounds more like may-care, as in, “I feel about Israeli occupation in the West Bank the same as I do about locating a woman’s G-spot during intercourse: I may-care.”
Fast forward a few hours: I threw up. Not sure if it was because I ate too much and wound up too full, or because I mixed—give or take—three hundred and twenty nine different types of alcohol. The jury it still out. I guess the fact that this was the outcome means I could’ve just started with beer and avoided that awkward moment at the bar, but then I wouldn’t have had a wonderful anecdote to share with you all, one that hopefully made you smile despite the fact it came at my personal cost. And I wouldn’t give that up for the world. That’s how much I love you all. You, your smile, is the reason I write; the reason I put myself through awkward moments; the reason I drink too much. And you always will be ❤
How did the night end, you ask? By me saying I wanna go home, biz.

P.S.

Ben and Jerry (the actual people, this time) came to speak at my undergrad once. I went and we were handed mini pints at the entrance. I gave mine to a girl I liked, saying, “I don’t even like ice cream,” thinking it would help get me chance with her. It didn’t. Should’ve kept the ice cream.

(Note to self: both this and the anecdote at the top can be used to write an essay about how the way to a woman’s heart is through ice cream. That’s innovative, original, groundbreaking. Never been done before. I should get to work on that now so it’s ready to publish by next year’s National Women’s Day.)

I don’t remember anything from B&J’s talk other than the fact that everything became heavily political at the end while they pushed their agenda. A valuable lesson was learned that day: Don’t trust old men who offer you sweets. If only I learned that when I was younger. But that’s a story for another day.

P.P.S.

Sorry, one last thing. Ben and Jerry get some hate in Israel because of their boycott of sales in occupied Palestinian territory. I don’t disagree with their stance. Even if I did, though, and you told me that keeping my morals would mean never having Phish Food again, well, then, lather me in gooey marshmallow swirls and toss me across the Green Line.

Leave a comment